The Top 30 Websites, Viewed in IE6
IE6 might be a "dying" browser, but many folks still use it. So how do the top 30 sites on the web look in IE6? No problems, or totally broken? Do they ask users to upgrade? This article reveals all!
Internet Explorer 6. Nine years on, it's still a headache for web designers and developers across the globe!
Most of us would like to forget about this horrid old browser — first launched in 2001, for crying out loud — but there's always that client or user who insists on using it (or is forced to by their employer). Even among the audience of W3Schools — a web-savvy crowd if ever there was one — there are still around 5% of visitors using IE6 at the time of writing.
The result of all this is that we are forced to spend hours of extra coding time, just to make our sites work in this outdated browser.
How many big sites these days actually bother supporting IE6?
But how many big sites these days actually bother supporting IE6? One might think that they all would, considering their huge user bases. But is this the case?
For this article, I fired up Alexa's Top 500 Global Sites list — this is a list of the most visited sites on the web, according to Alexa. I then worked my way through the top 30 sites in the list, testing them in IE6 running on a Windows 2000 Server SP4 virtual machine. I also tested them in Firefox 3.6.12 on the same VM, for comparison. Both browsers had the Flash plugin installed.
You'll find a screenshot of each site as it looks in IE6 (and occasionally Firefox). Sometimes I've shown the whole page, sometimes just a problem area within the page. I've also included a brief description of any problems found.
Generally I tested just the homepage of each site. However, if there's another page that better represents the experience of using the site then I've tested that page instead.
I've omitted several types of site from the list, for various reasons:
- Variants: Many sites are variants or country-specific versions of existing sites (google.com/.co.uk/.com.au etc).
- Non-English sites: Partly because I wouldn't be able to tell how broken the site was if I couldn't read it, and partly because Windows 2000's handling of Unicode is pretty bad.
- Ad network sites: I suspect they're in the Top 500 because of ad impressions, not because they're some of the sites most visited by people.
- Sites requiring login to work: Unless I happened to have a login for it.
- Porn sites: For the sake of decency.
A couple more caveats: I've only tested each site briefly, so there may well be IE6 issues in a site if you dig deep enough (if you find any please let me know in the article comments!). Also, of course, sites change all the time, so you might find that a site's IE6 compatibility has changed by the time you read this!
Although Google search works fine in IE6, with no layout issues, it does have reduced functionality. There are fewer options in the sidebar (see screenshot above), and Google's new "Instant Search" option is unavailable.
Facebook doesn't officially support IE6 any more, and once you've logged in you get a message encouraging you to upgrade. Certain features such as chat don't work either. That said, the site's still pretty much usable in IE6, with no major layout issues.
YouTube is a bit more insistent with its "upgrade your browser" messages. Again, though, the site seems to function pretty well in IE6. The main differences seem to be no Add to Favorites, Share or Embed buttons below the video, and everything looks a bit uglier.
Yahoo! works pretty much flawlessly in IE6. The only slight issue I spotted on the homepage was the word "Groups" being garbled when hovering over the "Finance" link (see screenshot).
Wikipedia is generally flawless in IE6, with slightly reduced functionality: the expandable content areas in the sidebar and footer are permanently expanded, with no option to fold them up (see screenshots above).
Blogger's admin functions seem to work fine with IE6. The only issue I spotted was that their new post editor doesn't work (you just get a blank screen), so you need to select the "Old editor" option under the Settings tab if you're using IE6.
The new Twitter interface (when you're logged in) is pretty screwed in IE6. There's no content in the right-hand panel, and it's hideously slow (and hits my MacBook Pro's i7 CPU pretty hard too). The top-right drop-down is partially hidden by the right-hand panel, and there are grey squares around many images, due to IE6's lack of PNG transparency support.
Amazon works perfectly in IE6. Flyout menus, videos, music samples — everything. I guess Amazon can't afford for it not to work...
WordPress.com is pretty broken in IE6, layout-wise. We're talking rectangles around images; boxes all over the place; and missing text in the top bar. One assumes that the WordPress folks don't care much about IE6...
LinkedIn's site seems to work pretty well in IE6. There's the odd issue like misaligned form fields (see screenshot), but otherwise good. (That said, I haven't logged in to explore the site further.)
eBay has various CSS issues in IE6. The red bar that should go all the way across the top only goes from the right hand edge to just after the green Search button. There are transparent PNG issues all over the place (grey rectangles), and the background images on the Sign In/Register buttons aren't repeating as they should. The site seems to basically work though.
Bing seems flawless in IE6. Even things like the video preview rollovers work. A vast improvement over MSN!
Flickr on IE6 is pretty much a no-go. Buttons are all over the place; rollovers explode into separate images; and random text overlaps the photos and other content. The site also wisely displays an "unsupported browser" banner along the top, advising you to upgrade.
Craigslist works perfectly in IE6. But let's face it, there's not much to go wrong!
Go generally works very well in IE6, with only the odd minor layout issue, such as the misaligned top-right ad in the screenshot above.
Myspace in IE6 is a bit of a train wreck, with a messed-up main menu and transparent PNG issues. Then again, Myspace isn't exactly beautiful in other browsers, is it? ;)
The Internet Movie Database
The IMDB is pretty good in IE6, with just the odd layout issue like the misaligned header in the screenshot above, and the odd transparent PNG rectangle. Movie listings and video trailers all work fine.
This is pretty funny. Try browsing the Mac page on the Apple site, and IE6 pops up a friendly dialog: "Internet Explorer cannot open the Internet site http://www.apple.com/mac/. Operation aborted". In other words: "How dare you try to defect to a Mac?!"
To be fair, the rest of the site works nearly flawlessly in IE6. :)
IE6 is at it again! As well as trying to stop you buying a Mac, it tries to stop you downloading Firefox by refusing to display its logo. IE will rule forever!
The rest of the site seems to just about function, although the "Add-ons" section is pretty screwed. Then again, you're unlikely to be browsing for Firefox add-ons using IE6...
Very impressed with the BBC. I couldn't find a single problem with IE6 on their main site or any of their sub-sites, including the design-heavy CBeebies site (see screenshot). Videos and Flash games all work perfectly.
Paypal's pretty minimalistic site works fine in IE6. There's the odd minor CSS issue, such as square borders around radio buttons, but no obvious functionality issues. Some pages feature a gentle warning to use a newer browser (see screenshot above) — this appears in all browsers, not just IE6.
AOL's very content-heavy homepage just about works OK in IE6, albeit with the odd missing ad and transparent PNG issue, as well as painful browser freezes/slowdowns. But check out the homepage in Firefox in the screenshot above. I've heard of ad-heavy sites but that's just ridiculous. Oops!
Adobe's done an impressive job with their site's IE6 compatibility. It looks practically identical on IE6 and Firefox. The only differences I found were sharp drop shadows around boxes (they're nicely blurred in other browsers), and no smooth opening/closing of the accordion items in the right hand sidebar. Otherwise, spot on. (This is partly down to the site's heavy reliance on Flash, of course.)
Ask.com is nearly flawless in IE6. All the search functionality is there, and there are no layout issues. There are small differences like no rounded corners on some boxes, and the odd transparent PNG issue, but that's about it.
CNN's site works okay in IE6, with no layout issues to speak of. On the minus side, the site's slow to load, videos are a bit jerky, and the Politics page reliably crashes the browser (see screenshot). Still, could be worse!
The chart below shows the broad spectrum of IE6 support across the top 30 websites, from flawless down to catastrophic:
Two things surprised me about these results:
- The wide range of IE6 compatibility levels across the 30 sites, from 100% compatible to basically not compatible at all.
- 27% of the top 30 sites have major visual or functionality problems that severely impact the experience for IE6 users.
Personally as a web coder I find these stats cheering. If major sites such as Twitter, WordPress.com and ESPN don't care about IE6 support, maybe the rest of us shouldn't care so much either? :)
What do you think of these results? I'd love to hear your thoughts in the comments below!
Responses to this article
10 responses (oldest first):
I know some designers who give clients a base price for a project, then give an additional cost for adding IE6 support. (It turns out that many clients would rather save the money!)
Though in my freelance work I too try to stay away from IE6-isms, it is a bit nerve racking when/if you have try and explain this to clients...
If only IE6 really were dead. It still keeps on getting up and walking around!
Simon from Elated pointed out that this article could be useful to show to clients who ask for IE6 support - it might just persuade them otherwise...
And I like the idea about charging extra for IE6 support...
Still missing a bit from my old days coming here regularly, but I will soon get back to my old life style, and whatever that means...
Great 2011 to you all and thank you for the post!
Cheers from Portugal
Let's see... Meanwhile I'll try to came back here as well as I used to, because of all this stuff in my life at the moment...
Thank you and cheers from Portugal to you all!
Catch up on sleep now while you can...
Hope all goes well for you this year with the baby and the business. Sounds like it'll be a busy year for you!
Post a response
Want to add a comment, or ask a question about this article? Post a response.
To post responses you need to be a member. Not a member yet? Signing up is free, easy and only takes a minute. Sign up now.